A Critical Theological Analysis
Not because he rejected the Temple. He replaced YHWH's eternal commands with "faith alone" and Greek spiritualism.
Before Paul, there was "The Way" (HaDerekh) ā the original Torah-observant path walked by Yeshua's disciples. Paul didn't restore The Way ā he replaced it with a Greek-Roman reinterpretation.
Examine the EvidenceCompare the original Torah-observant path with Paul's radical departure from Hebrew covenant practices.
The Original Hebrew Path
Mentioned in Acts 9:2 and Acts 24:14
Greek-Roman Replacement
A new religion, not The Way
Paul created his own religion that follows neither the Hebrew bible (like Yeshua) nor even the Greek bible he was raised on. This is separate from 4 other false religious systems of his time.
A Roman-Greek city filled with Stoic philosophy and pagan syncretism (Strabo, Geography 14.5.13). This environment shaped his theological framework.
Greek was his native language. He thought in Greek categories like "conscience" (syneidesis) and "flesh vs spirit" ā foreign to Hebrew thought.
Paul was raised on the 250 BC Greek Septuagint, but his teachings don't even match that. He created his own religion that follows neither Hebrew nor Greek sources.
Paul correctly avoided the corrupt Temple religion (Aramaic bible from Babylon). But instead of returning to Hebrew truth, he invented his own system.
Paul's teachings match neither the Hebrew bible (like Yeshua) nor the Greek bible he was raised on. He invented something entirely new.
Paul's religion, Temple system (Babylon Aramaic), Northern Jews (Greek + Egyptian paganism), Romans (Roman gods) ā none follow the Hebrew bible.
Paul's era had multiple competing religious systems ā none following the original Hebrew bible except Yeshua's way.
Religious System | Source Text | Key Characteristics |
---|---|---|
ā Yeshua's Way | Hebrew Bible | Torah observance, YHWH's commandments, original covenant path |
ā Paul's Religion | His Own Invention | Matches neither Hebrew nor Greek sources, "grace alone," Torah dead |
ā Temple System | Aramaic Bible (Babylon) | False rewritten texts, corrupt priesthood, religious ritual system |
ā Northern Jews | Greek Bible + Egyptian Paganism | 250 BC Septuagint mixed with pagan gods from Egypt |
ā Romans | Roman Religious Texts | Roman gods, emperor worship, imperial cult practices |
Trace how the original Hebrew Way was systematically replaced through six major transformations.
# | Event | What Changed |
---|---|---|
1 | Septuagint (250 BC) | Replaced Hebrew concepts with Greek philosophy. Removed YHWH's Name, turned justice into "righteousness." |
2 | Paul (30sā60s AD) | Preached "grace alone," rejected Torah. Replaced obedience with belief, covenant with spiritualized religion. |
3 | Constantine (325 AD) | Merged Paul, Rome, and paganism into the Catholic Church. Made Christianity the empire's religion. |
4 | Rabbinic Judaism (400ā600 AD) | Added oral law, vowels, and fences around Torah. Created Talmudic system separate from biblical text. |
5 | Islam (610ā632 AD) | Claimed Abraham's faith but rewrote the covenant. New prophet, new book, new practices. |
6 | Protestant Reformation (1517+) | Broke from Catholicism but kept Paul and Greek Bible. Reformed error instead of returning to Hebrew roots. |
Yeshua (Jesus) came to call Israel back to obedience ā not start a new religion.
Yeshua observed Sabbath, feasts, and commandments. He never taught "faith alone" or "grace over obedience."
Called people to turn from sin back to YHWH's ways. Repentance means returning to Torah obedience.
Never claimed equality with YHWH. Always pointed to the Father as the one true God of Israel.
His followers were called "The Way" ā not Christians. They continued Torah observance after his departure.
Paul's gospel is not Hebrew ā it's Greek.
It's not obedience ā it's excuse.
It's not from YHWH ā it's a lie built for empires.